Everyone should know I’m a fanboy of Seth, to the point of referring to him by only his first name, and not bothering with a link, assuming you MUST also be reading him.
But Seth is far from perfect.
So Murray points out at his sage blog, View From The Corner Office, titled: The Marketer Perfected:
“In a recent post, The Marketer’s Attitude, Godin describes the perfect marketer. It would be a high energy, relentlessly positive person. It would be someone self-motivated and self-sufficient, able not only to visualize complex projects but also to carry them through to fruition. He or she could engage strangers and embrace ambiguity. He sees the down streams and the downsides of any plan and adjusts accordingly. And so on.”
Yes, I read that post by Seth at least twice, seeing if I could mentally measure myself up to his ideal. I can’t say that I felt I was. But in B2B, you have to be more pragmatic. Murray, from the vantage of retired marketer/sales VP saw the hole in the perfection:
“There was something missing from his description, however. The perfect marketer must also be the perfect politician. The astute marketer knows that, in a perfect world, all things are possible. But in a highly volatile world, where people see their investments and imagine their lives going down the rabbit hole, where Boards are insecure and CEOs intractable and budget cuts inescapable, not all things are possible. Indeed, most things – even the small things and especially the right things – require a great deal of personal conviction and much cleverness to gain the collaboration of those in high places if projects are to ever see the light of day.”
Now, Murray is not the first to pick on Seth. But in this case, he adds value. Because without conquering the politics, your ideas remain just that–yours.
(Hmmm. Looks like I’ve given Murray the same one-name treatment. Completely unplanned, honest.)